Having previously discussed the verdict in the case brought against The Pirate Bay, perhaps I should not get distracted by other similar court cases, as this blog is not a running commentary on file sharing news. However, there is an important issue which I mentioned last time about where the courts will draw the line between Google and The Pirate Bay, and whether that line can stop a significant amount of copyright infringement without stopping a significant amount of legal online activity. The BREIN vs. Mininova case provides another interesting data point, testing the legal waters (despite the case being heard in a slightly different jurisdiction) which might inform other websites how they should operate to remain legal. I actually think that although the cases, and their verdicts, were similar, the Mininova case involved fewer dubious legal steps from the judge, but perhaps that’s because I have only read a Google translation of the verdict. In any case, I detail below my understanding of the trial and its consequences for operators of websites.
Continue reading "The Mininova verdict"